Advertiser Disclosure: The Rewards Mom has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. The Rewards Mom and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers.
I’ll never forget the moment I stretched out in a lie-flat seat on my flight to Rome. The ticket would have cost nearly $2,800. Instead, I used 60,000 points I’d earned from my credit card. If I had chosen cash back, those same points would have given me about $600 off my statement. Both are valuable, but when the difference is $2,200, there’s really no comparison in my book.
The debate in the credit card world is should you choose the simplicity of cash back or the extra value of flexible points? Let’s look at some real-life examples and tips so you can decide which works best for your family travel plans.
If you’re just getting started with points, my Beginner’s Guide is a great place to start.
Why Cash Back Works
Cash back is a straightforward option. For every dollar you spend, you earn a percentage back, often between 1% and 5%, depending on the card and purchase category. Those rewards can be redeemed as statement credits, bank deposits, or gift cards.
When you’re already juggling a million things, the idea of learning more than a simple redemption feels like one thing too many. Just saving money in any way can feel like a win (because it is!).
Cash back:
- Works for any expense (groceries, gas, kids’ sports fees)
- Doesn’t require planning or strategy to redeem
- Helps with everyday budget relief instead of tying value to travel
Example:
Let’s say you spend $2,000 a month on family expenses. If your card earns 2% cash back, that’s $40 a month, or nearly $500 a year, back in your pocket. That’s real savings for things like catching up on bills or Christmas gifts.
If you’re in a season where the focus is covering bills or cutting monthly expenses, cash back can absolutely make sense. It’s simple and it helps immediately. Sometimes, that’s exactly what you need. Even if you’re technically redeeming at a lower value by choosing cash back, if you’re following the steps in my beginner’s guide to earn more points, you will still coming out ahead compared to where you started. When life slows down enough to plan a trip, those points can stretch so much further. And if the organization piece feels overwhelming, I promise there are ways to make it doable so you really can take that trip.
Why Flexible Points Can Deliver More Value
In the cash back vs. flexible points credit cards debate, remember that flexible points take more effort but can stretch your spending into incredible experiences. Instead of redeeming at a flat rate, you can often transfer points to airlines and hotels, which is where you unlock maximum value.
1- My Rome flight: For 60,000 points, I could have redeemed $600 cash back. Instead, I transferred those points to an airline partner and booked a $2,800 lie-flat seat. That’s nearly 5 cents per point in value.
2- A Hyatt stay: Hyatt has an award chart where nights often cost 12,000–20,000 points, even when cash rates are over $400. That means one card bonus could cover multiple nights for a family. If you want to know how to calculate the value of these points, click here.
3- Flying Southwest: Families love Southwest for its free checked bags and flexible policies. Using points (and especially pairing with the Companion Pass) can make family flights far more affordable. Here’s how we flew our family of six to Hawaii using points. The cash price for these flights would have been much higher.
But How Do I Do It?
Transferring Points
Whichever credit card program you use, you’ll need to know which partners transfer. What do I mean by this? Every flexible points card has partners that they transfer to. You take all the points you have earned from the bank, and then transfer them to your favorite hotel chain or airline carrier. I cover all of that more in detail in How to Transfer Credit Card Points to Travel Partners (And Why It’s Worth It).
Help for Booking
Sometimes, award space isn’t always available on the exact dates you want. This can get frustrating, and you might think why did I go to all this effort when I can’t even book anything? I promise you can. You might just need a little help. This blog post on the best apps to book travel with points might help.
Yes it can take some planning, but if travel is a priority for your family, just a few extra steps can unlock savings of thousands of dollars a year. I’ve taken trips I literally didn’t think I would ever be able to save the cash for, all thanks to points and miles.
Cash Back vs. Flexible Points : Side-by-Side
| If You… | Cash Back Might Be Best | Flexible Points Might Be Best |
|---|---|---|
| Want pure simplicity | Rewards are easy to earn and redeem | Points require more planning |
| Need flexibility for any expense | Works on groceries, gas, bills | Travel redemptions only |
| Don’t travel often | Cash offsets everyday spending | Rewards may sit unused |
| Want to maximize big value trips | Limited to flat value per point | Can unlock 3–5x (or more) in value |
| Dream of luxury travel for less | Cash won’t stretch as far | Premium cabins & resorts possible |
The Balanced Approach
With cash back vs. flexible points credit cards, you don’t have to choose one or the other! Many families use both: a cash-back card for daily essentials, and a flexible points card for vacations.
Whichever card you choose, make sure you are working toward a minimum spend as often as possible. Minimum spends are where you hit your welcome bonus, which turn into even more cash back to help you budget or earn points faster you can turn into family trips or luxury splurges.
If you want to dip into flexible points but keep things simple, I recommend starting with my free beginners guide. If you’re ready to start earning, apply for one of my favorite beginner cards.
Final Takeaway
There’s no such thing as a bad redemption. If you’re saving money, you’re winning. If you’re looking for simplicity and flexibility, cash back is always a safe bet. But if your family values experiences and you’re willing to plan ahead, flexible points can give you 3–5x the value.
I’ll always remember that Rome flight, especially the look on my husband’s face when we got to our seats. Not because it was glamorous (though it was), but because it showed me how powerful points can be when used strategically.
Cash back vs.flexible points? In the end, the “winner” is whichever strategy helps you reach your family’s goals, whether that’s keeping groceries affordable this month or waking up in Rome next summer.
Want to start earning free family travel? Grab my free Beginner’s Guide to Points.
Want daily tips and examples like this? Join me on Instagram, hop in our Facebook group, or subscribe to my email list for the best deals delivered right to your inbox.
VIEW THE COMMENTS